PART 2
The police searched the school, the woods, and the river.
Weeks later, they told us Livia had contacted them. She was safe. But because she was an adult, she did not have to reveal her location.
I refused to accept it.
In my mind, she had been manipulated. Taken. Turned against us.
After that night, Liam changed.
He stopped laughing. He locked his bedroom door whenever he was inside. If I knocked, he answered through the wood.
“Please, Mom. Just don’t come in.”
I thought it was grief.
So I respected it.
Around Christmas, John tried to say what I refused to hear.
“Camila, she was eighteen.”
I looked up from Livia’s empty stocking. “Don’t.”
“Maybe she left.”
“She would never do that to me.”
John looked exhausted.
“Maybe that sentence is part of the problem.”
By August, Liam left for college.
At his car, I tried to hug him.
He let me, but barely.
“Don’t disappear on me too,” I whispered.
His eyes filled. “I’m trying not to.”
A month later, I smelled smoke coming from under his bedroom door.
Liam was away. John was at work. I was upstairs alone when the smell reached me — sharp, burnt, wrong.
His door was locked.
I used a small screwdriver until the lock gave way, then pushed it open.
There was no fire, only a scorched power strip beside his desk. I yanked the cord from the wall.
Then I saw the photo.
The prom picture.
Livia smiling beside Liam, already hiding a secret.
My legs weakened, and I sank onto his yellow beanbag chair.
Something underneath me felt strange.
Too soft in one spot.
Too hard in another.
I flipped it over.
A long seam ran across the bottom, stitched with bright red thread.
Liam had never known how to sew.
But Livia had.
My hands trembled as I pulled the thread loose.
The fabric tore open.
First came pale blue satin.
Then my daughter’s prom dress slid into my lap.
After that came envelopes. Dozens of them. All addressed to Liam.
Then photographs. A courthouse picture. A sonogram. A hospital bracelet. A tiny photo of a baby in yellow.
Finally, one sealed envelope fell near my foot.
On the front, Livia had written:
Mom — only if she can listen.
I screamed.
John found me on the floor twenty minutes later, surrounded by letters.
I held up the dress.
“She wasn’t taken,” I whispered.
John picked up the courthouse photo.
“Mitchell?”
“They’re married,” I said.
I opened the first letter with shaking hands.
Livia had written to Liam, asking him not to hate her. She had changed out of her dress after prom and begged him to hide it before I saw it. She wrote that she knew I would assume the worst.
But she had chosen to leave.
Another letter said Mitchell had begged her to call me.
He had told her I loved her.
But Livia wrote:
That’s the problem. She loves me like a locked door.
I kept reading.
Natalie had opened the door to Livia in the middle of the night and taken her in without blame, without judgment, without demanding answers.
I wanted to hate Natalie.
Instead, shame burned through me.
The sonogram was dated six weeks after prom.
The hospital bracelet showed that Livia’s baby, Rose, was already three months old.
In one letter, Livia wrote that after giving birth, she wanted me so badly she dialed half my number. Then she remembered something cruel I had once said about another pregnant girl, and she hung up before the call went through.
John whispered, “Open the one for you.”
I didn’t want to.
Which meant I had to.
In the letter, Livia asked me not to punish Liam. She said she had a daughter named Rose, named after my mother, because she wanted one piece of home that did not hurt.
Then she wrote the line that broke me:
I need to know if you can love me without owning me.
If yes, ask Liam where I am.
If no, please let me stay gone.
